Other Uses of the Term
As one might expect, there have been other uses of the term `cultural
phenomenology'. The work of the German sociologist Alfred Schutz, for example,
is often described in this way. During the 1930s, Schutz, who was associated
with the Frankfurt Institute for Social Research, attempted to graft the
insights and procedures of Husserlian phenomenology on to a Weberian form
of social theory: his major work, Der sinnhafte Aufbau der sozialen
Welt, was written in 1932, and has been translated as The Phenomenology
of the Social World. Schutz's sociologised
phenomenology is an extremely formalist and positivist affair. I think David
Carr captures the limitations of Schutz's project well, when he criticises
his too-exclusive focus upon the cognitive forms of social life, or the forms
of intersubjective understanding, rather than other kinds of relation and
experience:
Another more recent claimant for the term cultural phenomenology is Thomas
J. Csordas, who has recently used it to characterise his investigations into
charismatic healing practices. Csordas brings to his material an anthropologist's
emphasis on the ways in which human beings make themselves and their humanity
through their practices.
Csordas's account of the dual focus of his cultural phenomenology - on lived
experience and the shared conditions of cultural making - is one that I find
it easy to agree with. `Cultural phenomenology', he writes, `represents a
concern for synthesising the immediacy of embodied experience with the
multiplicity of cultural meanings in which we are always and inevitably
immersed.'
|
| Steve Connor | English and Humanities | Birkbeck College |